fix(security): bound password input before zxcvbn, and drop the legacy media mounts

Two findings from the GHSA-pwx6-5pqc-c5xq scan bundle, both verified against
the code and reproduced before fixing.

**Unauthenticated denial of service via password strength (csf_495d53fa).**
POST /api/auth/password-strength takes `body('password').notEmpty()` with no
upper bound, sits behind express.json({ limit: '50mb' }), and hands the string
to zxcvbn, whose matching is superlinear and runs synchronously on the event
loop. Measured on this codebase, in ms of blocked loop: 128 -> 41, 512 -> 1367,
1000 -> 5097, 5000 -> did not return in two minutes. One unauthenticated
request of about a kilobyte stops the whole process for five seconds; a few
kilobytes stops it indefinitely. The /api/auth rate limit does not help when a
single request is already enough.

The cap lives in validatePassword() so it covers every caller, present and
future; the route validator is defence in depth. 128 keeps the worst case at
the cost of an ordinary request while staying far above any real password --
bcrypt consumes only the first 72 bytes, so length past that adds no entropy to
the stored hash anyway. This is the only unauthenticated reach into zxcvbn:
setup is token-gated and self-closing, and acceptInvite/adminAuth use the
regex-only validator in passwordGenerator.

**The /photos and /thumbnails static mounts (csf_9aa6afe6, csf_559cd5cc,
csf_b14d462e, csf_547d26fa, and the gallery half of csf_34e420af).**
They served the raw originals and thumbnail trees behind photoAuth, which
authorises on a slug match. A static file server cannot apply per-photo rules,
so everything the gallery API decides was absent: allow_downloads, per-category
allow_downloads, watermarking, the resolution cap, reveal-mode windows,
visibility='hidden', download logging, and the customer-assignment re-check
that makes revocation immediate. photoAuth also bcrypt-compares an
x-gallery-password header per request with no limiter -- both rate-limit gates
return early for non-/api paths -- so the mount was an unmetered password
oracle. The filenames needed to drive all of this are handed to every guest in
the photos listing.

Nothing builds these URLs: no reference in frontend/src, none in the email
templates, and the only backend mentions are the /api/admin/photos/... API
routes and a maintenance-mode prefix list. The equivalent authorised routes are
/api/gallery/:slug/photo/:id and /thumbnail/:id. nginx still proxies the two
locations; they now 404, which is the intent.

**The /uploads mount (csf_1fc92f57).** It exposed the whole uploads/ root with
no auth middleware at all, and that root also holds signed contract PDFs
(uploads/contracts/signed) and client transfer files (uploads/transfers/<id>),
reachable by anyone who learned or guessed a filename. Narrowed to the two
public asset trees it exists for; contracts and transfers keep their own
authorised routes.

Removing the mounts leaves src/middleware/photoAuth.js unreferenced by
application code. Left in place deliberately -- deleting it and its tests is a
separate cleanup, and a smaller diff backports more safely.

Backend suite: 2742 passed.
This commit is contained in:
Paul Nothaft
2026-09-03 09:14:48 +02:00
parent a87e688484
commit 14cd5eacb3
4 changed files with 115 additions and 8 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
/**
* POST /api/auth/password-strength is unauthenticated and feeds its body into
* zxcvbn, whose matching is superlinear and runs synchronously on the event
* loop. Behind express.json({ limit: '50mb' }) that made a single request a
* whole-process denial of service: measured on this codebase, 1,000 characters
* blocked for ~5 seconds and 5,000 did not return in two minutes.
*
* The control is the length cap inside validatePassword(), so it holds for
* every caller. These tests pin the cap itself rather than the route, and use
* a wall-clock ceiling that only an unbounded zxcvbn call can breach.
*/
const { validatePassword, MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH } = require('../../src/utils/passwordValidation');
describe('password validation length cap (zxcvbn DoS)', () => {
it('rejects an over-length password without doing superlinear work', () => {
const huge = 'aA1!'.repeat(MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH); // 4x the cap
const started = Date.now();
const result = validatePassword(huge);
const elapsed = Date.now() - started;
expect(result.valid).toBe(false);
expect(result.errors.join(' ')).toMatch(/at most 128 characters/);
// Unbounded, this input would not return for minutes.
expect(elapsed).toBeLessThan(250);
});
it('is bounded at the cap itself, the worst input it will still analyse', () => {
const atCap = 'aA1!'.repeat(MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH / 4);
expect(atCap).toHaveLength(MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH);
// 128 was chosen so the worst input the validator will still analyse costs
// about as much as an ordinary request (~41ms measured); 512 cost 1.4s.
const started = Date.now();
validatePassword(atCap);
expect(Date.now() - started).toBeLessThan(1000);
});
it('still accepts an ordinary strong password', () => {
const result = validatePassword('Tr0ub4dour&3-horse-battery');
expect(result.valid).toBe(true);
});
it('applies the cap through the context wrapper too', async () => {
const { validatePasswordInContext } = require('../../src/utils/passwordValidation');
const huge = 'aA1!'.repeat(MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH);
const result = await validatePasswordInContext(huge, 'admin', {});
expect(result.valid).toBe(false);
});
});
+28 -7
View File
@@ -596,14 +596,35 @@ const secureStatic = require('./src/middleware/secureStatic');
const storagePath = process.env.STORAGE_PATH || path.join(__dirname, '../storage');
process.env.EXTERNAL_MEDIA_ROOT = process.env.EXTERNAL_MEDIA_ROOT || '/external-media';
// Static file serving for photos (protected)
app.use('/photos', require('./src/middleware/photoAuth'), setCorsHeaders, secureStatic(path.join(storagePath, 'events/active')));
// The /photos and /thumbnails static mounts are gone.
//
// They served the raw originals tree and the thumbnail tree behind photoAuth
// alone, which authorises on a slug match. A static file server cannot apply
// the rules the gallery API applies per photo, so everything the API decides
// was simply absent here: allow_downloads, per-category allow_downloads,
// watermarking, the resolution cap, reveal-mode windows, visibility='hidden',
// download logging, and the customer-assignment re-check that lets an admin
// revoke access immediately. The filenames needed to exercise it are handed to
// every guest in the photos listing.
//
// Nothing builds these URLs: no reference in frontend/src, none in the email
// templates, and the only backend mentions are the /api/admin/photos/... API
// routes and a maintenance-mode prefix list. nginx still proxies /photos and
// /thumbnails; those locations now 404, which is the intended outcome.
//
// Serving these safely would mean reimplementing per-photo authorisation and
// image processing inside a static handler -- i.e. the gallery API, which
// already exists at /api/gallery/:slug/photo/:id and /thumbnail/:id.
// Static file serving for thumbnails (protected)
app.use('/thumbnails', require('./src/middleware/photoAuth'), setCorsHeaders, secureStatic(path.join(storagePath, 'thumbnails')));
// Static file serving for uploads (public - logos, favicons)
app.use('/uploads', setCorsHeaders, secureStatic(path.join(storagePath, 'uploads')));
// Static file serving for uploads.
//
// Narrowed to the two public asset trees. The mount used to expose the whole
// uploads/ root with no auth middleware at all, and that root also holds
// signed contract PDFs (uploads/contracts/signed) and client transfer files
// (uploads/transfers/<id>) -- both reachable by anyone who learned or guessed
// a filename. Those are served by their own authorised routes.
app.use('/uploads/logos', setCorsHeaders, secureStatic(path.join(storagePath, 'uploads/logos')));
app.use('/uploads/favicons', setCorsHeaders, secureStatic(path.join(storagePath, 'uploads/favicons')));
// Static file serving for self-hosted webfonts (public — gallery visitors
// load these via @font-face). Replaces the previous Google Fonts CDN
+10 -1
View File
@@ -33,6 +33,7 @@ const { getClientIp } = require('../utils/requestIp');
const { sanitizePasswordInput } = require('../utils/passwordInput');
const {
validatePasswordInContext,
MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH,
getBcryptRounds,
logPasswordValidationFailure
} = require('../utils/passwordValidation');
@@ -952,8 +953,16 @@ router.post('/admin/change-password', [
});
// Password strength check endpoint (for real-time validation)
//
// Unauthenticated, and it feeds the request body straight into zxcvbn, whose
// matching is superlinear and synchronous. Without the length bound a single
// request stops the event loop for the whole process -- ~5s at 1,000
// characters and unbounded past that. validatePassword() enforces the same cap
// for every caller; this one keeps the oversized body from being accepted at
// the edge at all.
router.post('/password-strength', [
body('password').notEmpty(),
body('password').isString().isLength({ min: 1, max: MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH })
.withMessage(`Password must be 1-${MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH} characters`),
body('context').isIn(['admin', 'gallery']).optional()
], async (req, res) => {
try {
+28
View File
@@ -7,6 +7,21 @@ const zxcvbn = require('zxcvbn');
const logger = require('./logger');
// Configuration
// zxcvbn's matching is superlinear in the input length and runs synchronously
// on the event loop, so an unbounded password is a denial-of-service primitive
// rather than a slow request. The reachable caller is
// POST /api/auth/password-strength, which is unauthenticated and sits behind
// express.json({ limit: '50mb' }) -- one request stops the whole process.
//
// Measured on this codebase (ms of blocked event loop per call):
// 64 -> 12 128 -> 41 192 -> 105 256 -> 218
// 384 -> 632 512 -> 1367 1000 -> 5097 5000 -> did not return in 2 min
//
// 128 keeps the worst case at the cost of an ordinary request while staying
// far above any real password: bcrypt consumes only the first 72 bytes, so
// anything longer already adds no entropy to the stored hash.
const MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH = 128;
const PASSWORD_CONFIG = {
minLength: 8, // Reduced from 12 to 8 for better usability
requireUppercase: true,
@@ -34,6 +49,18 @@ const COMMON_PASSWORDS = [
function validatePassword(password, options = {}) {
const config = { ...PASSWORD_CONFIG, ...options };
const errors = [];
// Bail before any superlinear work touches the string. This is the guard for
// every caller, including ones added later -- the per-route length validator
// is defence in depth, not the control.
if (typeof password === 'string' && password.length > MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH) {
return {
valid: false,
errors: [`Password must be at most ${MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH} characters`],
score: 0,
feedback: {},
};
}
// Check if password exists
if (!password || typeof password !== 'string') {
@@ -366,6 +393,7 @@ function logPasswordValidationFailure(context, errors, metadata = {}) {
}
module.exports = {
MAX_PASSWORD_LENGTH,
validatePassword,
validatePasswordInContext,
generateSecurePassword,