Paul Nothaft
ab2c3db679
Schrittweiser Plan fuer alle offenen Punkte inkl. Abnahmekriterien je Schritt, Nachschlagereferenz und Definition of Done. Ergaenzt die Entscheidungen vom 2026-08-11: kein Electron (Capacitor bzw. PWA) und kein eigenes Backend (HA-API direkt).
244 lines
15 KiB
Markdown
244 lines
15 KiB
Markdown
# AGENTS.md — Project state, review findings, open items, and working rules
|
||
|
||
**Last updated: 2026-08-11** (full-repo review). This file is the entry point for every new agent
|
||
session: what this repo is, what is finished, what is missing, and how to work here. Detail lives in
|
||
the linked documents — this file points, it does not duplicate.
|
||
|
||
> **Maintenance rule (binding):** whenever you change this repo in a way that affects anything
|
||
> recorded here — completing an open item, making or reversing a decision, adding/removing a
|
||
> component, discovering a new gap — **update this file in the same session** (tick the checkbox,
|
||
> adjust the status table, bump the "Last updated" date). This file must always be written in
|
||
> **English**, even though the rest of the project is German.
|
||
|
||
**How this file is loaded:** Claude Code does not read `AGENTS.md` natively; the root `CLAUDE.md`
|
||
imports it via `@AGENTS.md` (official recommended pattern). Other agents (Codex, Cursor, Copilot)
|
||
read `AGENTS.md` directly. Edit content here, not in `CLAUDE.md`.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Working rules
|
||
|
||
### Karpathy guidelines (adopted as project standard)
|
||
|
||
From [`multica-ai/andrej-karpathy-skills`](https://github.com/multica-ai/andrej-karpathy-skills),
|
||
behavioral rules derived from Andrej Karpathy's observations on LLM coding failures. They bias
|
||
toward caution over speed — for trivial tasks, use judgment.
|
||
|
||
1. **Think before coding.** Don't assume. Don't hide confusion. Surface tradeoffs. State
|
||
assumptions explicitly; if multiple interpretations exist, present them — don't pick silently.
|
||
If a simpler approach exists, say so. Push back when warranted. If something is unclear, stop
|
||
and ask.
|
||
2. **Simplicity first.** Minimum code that solves the problem. Nothing speculative: no features
|
||
beyond what was asked, no abstractions for single-use code, no unrequested configurability, no
|
||
error handling for impossible scenarios. If 200 lines could be 50, rewrite.
|
||
3. **Surgical changes.** Touch only what you must. Don't "improve" adjacent code, comments, or
|
||
formatting; don't refactor what isn't broken; match existing style. Remove only orphans **your**
|
||
change created; mention (don't delete) pre-existing dead code. Every changed line should trace
|
||
directly to the request.
|
||
4. **Goal-driven execution.** Define success criteria, loop until verified. "Fix the bug" → write a
|
||
test that reproduces it, then make it pass. For multi-step tasks, state a brief plan with a
|
||
verify step per item.
|
||
|
||
### Claude Code practices (current guidance, 2026)
|
||
|
||
- Keep this file **concise and specific** — instructions concrete enough to verify ("run X before
|
||
Y"), markdown headers/bullets, no dense prose. Context files reduce adherence as they grow;
|
||
target roughly ≤200 lines of actual instruction.
|
||
- Don't record here what the code or git history already shows (directory dumps, dependency
|
||
lists) — record pitfalls, rationale, decisions, and conventions that differ from defaults.
|
||
- Conflicting instructions get picked arbitrarily — when updating, **remove** superseded rules
|
||
rather than stacking corrections.
|
||
- Verify loading with `/context` (file must appear under **Memory files**); edit via `/memory`.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## What this project is
|
||
|
||
Private replacement for the Audi *connect plug & play* app (discontinued end of 2026), for exactly
|
||
one vehicle (**Audi RS 4 Avant competition**), single user, self-hosted on Home Assistant, access
|
||
via Tailscale only. Read-only toward the vehicle — no remote control. Covers: vehicle status, trip
|
||
log, fuel log with Shell receipt parsing, service forecasting, insurance/tax, tire management.
|
||
|
||
**License rule (hard):** Audi Type fonts, four-rings SVG, and model-badge SVGs are cleared **only
|
||
for this one private, unpublished installation**. Therefore `design-system/` is brand-free (it gets
|
||
uploaded to Claude Design), while the HA panel and the future sideload-only app may use the real
|
||
assets. Never mix these the other way around.
|
||
|
||
**Reading order for a new session:**
|
||
1. This file (overview + open items)
|
||
2. `UMSETZUNGSPLAN.md` — the step-by-step execution plan for all open items (13 phases with
|
||
commands and acceptance criteria); when working on an open item, follow the plan's phase
|
||
3. `SPECIFICATION.md` — authoritative for the HA panel, incl. §7 "Known Gaps"
|
||
4. `COMPANION_APP_ARCHITECTURE.md` — authoritative for DataMetric360 (decided, barely built)
|
||
5. `AUDIT_2026-08-10.md` — accessibility/platform audit of the panel (partly done, rest below)
|
||
6. `bauauftrag.md` — **historical only**; code has diverged (see SPECIFICATION.md §7)
|
||
|
||
## The three projects in this repo
|
||
|
||
| Area | What | Status |
|
||
|---|---|---|
|
||
| `homeassistant/` | HA panel (`panel_custom`): pyscript backend + vanilla-JS frontend | ✅ **finished, in use** |
|
||
| `design-system/` | React component library `@audi-dash/ui`, brand-free, feeds Claude Design | ✅ done as a kit (20 components, 1,690 lines) |
|
||
| `companion-app/` | **DataMetric360** — successor app (Capacitor iOS/Android + HA iframe); will **replace** the panel | 🚧 data layer only (~930 lines TS), **no UI** |
|
||
| `design/` | Export of the Claude Design draft for DataMetric360 | 🚧 interim (wrong model, main screens only) |
|
||
|
||
Root files: `dashboard-muster*.html` = original static prototype (superseded, reference only),
|
||
`bauauftrag.md`/`.html` = original build brief (historical), `DESIGN_BRIEF_DATAMETRIC360.md` = the
|
||
prompt for the Claude Design project.
|
||
|
||
**`homeassistant/` in one paragraph:** 10 pyscript scripts + 4 modules (`pyscript/modules/`); trip
|
||
detection via the iPhone WLAN sensor with pause tolerance, two-stage trip completion via HA history
|
||
screening (odometer often updates only on the next trip), fill-up detection on fuel-level rise,
|
||
Shell PDF parser (`data/shell_beleg_parser.py`, subprocess, the only tested part of the repo), tire
|
||
km counter, backup, self-update, image management. Frontend: one file `www/audi-dashboard-app.js`
|
||
(3,130 lines, custom element, no framework/bundler), 5 tabs + ~19 detail routes, cache-busting via
|
||
`audi-dashboard-version.json` + loader stub. Entity IDs configured centrally in
|
||
`pyscript/modules/einstellungen.py` (the one file edited before install). Deploy: `update.ps1`
|
||
(robocopy to Samba share) or — still inactive — self-update from git.
|
||
|
||
**`companion-app/` — what exists:** dependency-free, strictly typed TS data layer (`src/api/`):
|
||
REST client (`rest.ts`), WebSocket client with auth flow + reconnect backoff (`live.ts`),
|
||
persistent offline write queue (`warteschlange.ts`, strict FIFO), environment detection
|
||
capacitor/iframe/browser (`umgebung.ts`), types + entity table (`types.ts`), facade
|
||
`DataMetricApi` (`index.ts`). Smoke test ran 7/7 green against Docker HA `audi_ha_test`
|
||
(localhost:18123) — unauthenticated only; token-authenticated reads/writes untested.
|
||
|
||
**DataMetric360 architecture (short — details in `COMPANION_APP_ARCHITECTURE.md`):**
|
||
- Future data source: **Teltonika FMM003** on the CAN bus, fully replacing the iPhone WLAN sensor
|
||
and the VAG integration.
|
||
- **Current data path (since 2026-08-11): Codec JSON → MQTT/TLS → Mosquitto add-on → HA.** Traccar
|
||
is **dropped** (the decision log deliberately remains in the architecture doc, marked ÜBERHOLT).
|
||
- Frontend access: HA REST + WebSocket with a long-lived access token (no `hass` object).
|
||
- External access: Cloudflare Tunnel + reverse proxy with a path allowlist; HA itself stays
|
||
unreachable. Domain **`datametric360.app`** registered (all-inkl, 2026-08-11).
|
||
- Distribution: **sideload only** (license reason) — hence real Audi assets are allowed there.
|
||
- Trip detection moves to FMM003 ignition; the pause-tolerance feature
|
||
(`fahrten_pausenzeit_min`) is a deliberate product decision and must be preserved.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Review findings (2026-08-11)
|
||
|
||
### HA panel — known gaps (most also in SPECIFICATION.md §7)
|
||
|
||
- **GPS is dead schema:** `start_lat/lon`, addresses, `route`, `avg_speed_kmh` never populated.
|
||
The trip-detail map draws a **fabricated** line via `fakeTrack()`
|
||
(`audi-dashboard-app.js:414`) — not a real track.
|
||
- **No GPS fallback in trip completion:** trips without an odometer match stay `status="offen"`
|
||
forever (`modules/fahrtabschluss_logik.py:16-20`).
|
||
- **RAM-only state:** running trip (`_fahrt_start_ts`) and fuel low-water-mark
|
||
(`_tiefststand_pct`) do not survive an HA restart. Deliberately deferred hardening.
|
||
- **Inactive features:** `BATTERIE_SENSOR = ""` (entire battery-history feature is a no-op) and
|
||
`UPDATE_REPO_URL = ""` (self-update inactive), both in `pyscript/modules/einstellungen.py`.
|
||
`www/bilder/` has no vehicle photos (all slots show placeholders); `steuer.faellig` unset.
|
||
- **Robustness:** `profil_lesen()` in `modules/profil.py` does not handle a missing/corrupt
|
||
`fahrzeugprofil.json` — all callers throw.
|
||
- **Tests:** only the receipt parser is tested (`data/tests/test_shell_beleg_parser.py`, 10 real
|
||
receipts) — and its test PDFs are gitignored, so a fresh clone can't run it. Backend and
|
||
frontend: no tests, no CI.
|
||
- **Leaflet via CDN:** trip map needs public internet in addition to the Tailscale tunnel.
|
||
|
||
### Documentation drift (small fixes; align docs to code)
|
||
|
||
- `homeassistant/README.md:99`, `INSTALL.md:204`, and the header comment
|
||
`audi-dashboard-app.js:13-15` claim the statistics view shows sample numbers — **false**;
|
||
`vStat()` computes real values from `TRIPS`/`FILLS`.
|
||
- `INSTALL.md` step 4 names variables that no longer exist (`DOORS_SENSOR`, `WINDOWS_SENSOR`,
|
||
`LOCK_ENTITY`, `BATTERY_VOLTAGE_SENSOR`) — actual names: `TUER_SENSOREN`/`FENSTER_SENSOREN`/
|
||
`TUERSCHLOSS_SENSOREN`/`BATTERIE_SENSOR`.
|
||
- `homeassistant/README.md:110` mentions the removed 97% full-tank rule (removal documented in
|
||
`belegverarbeitung.py:18-20`); the README file list omits 5 pyscript files.
|
||
- Obsolete comment `belegverarbeitung.py:41` ("TODO: Datei ablegen" — file has long existed).
|
||
|
||
### Audit leftovers (`AUDIT_2026-08-10.md` §4, deliberately left open)
|
||
|
||
- 🟠 Swipe-to-delete has no gesture-free fallback — screen-reader/switch-control users cannot
|
||
delete trips/fill-ups. Needs a design decision (long-press vs. "…" button vs. action sheet).
|
||
- 🟡 Popup close-by-tap-outside is not keyboard-reachable (needs a quick manual check).
|
||
- 🟡 Self-host Leaflet JS/CSS (tiles necessarily stay remote).
|
||
- Audit's own note: these three may be better done in DataMetric360 than retrofitted — the panel
|
||
gets replaced anyway.
|
||
|
||
### companion-app / design-system
|
||
|
||
- **Not wired together:** `companion-app` does not reference `@audi-dash/ui` anywhere (no
|
||
dependency, no import, no workspace root). The link exists only in prose.
|
||
- Both packages: no `node_modules`, no `dist` — smoke tests need `npm install` first
|
||
(design-system additionally `npm run build`; `scripts/smoke.mjs` imports from `../dist/`).
|
||
- No unit tests, no Storybook (substitute: SSR smoke over 21 cases in design-system).
|
||
- `design/` export (2026-08-11) has two known, already-commissioned fixes not yet in the export:
|
||
shows **RS 6 instead of RS 4**, and **16 sub-pages** the HA panel already has are missing
|
||
(list in `design/README.md`).
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Open items
|
||
|
||
Execution order, exact steps, and acceptance criteria for every item below live in
|
||
`UMSETZUNGSPLAN.md` (phases 1–13). Additional decisions of 2026-08-11: **no Electron** (Capacitor
|
||
wraps the web app for iPhone; a PWA home-screen install is the accepted intermediate step) and
|
||
**no separate backend** (the app talks to the HA REST/WebSocket API directly).
|
||
|
||
### A) Build DataMetric360 (the big block)
|
||
|
||
- [ ] Fix the Claude Design draft (RS 4, not RS 6) and extend it by the 16 missing sub-pages;
|
||
then re-export to `design/`
|
||
- [ ] `companion-app`: set up Vite + React + Capacitor scaffold; wire `@audi-dash/ui` as a real
|
||
dependency (possibly add a workspace/monorepo root)
|
||
- [ ] Implement the screens from the design draft on top of the existing `DataMetricApi` layer
|
||
- [ ] Add Audi assets (fonts/rings/badges) at implementation time from `homeassistant/www/` —
|
||
**never** into `design-system/`
|
||
- [ ] Secure storage for the LLAT (iOS Keychain / Android Keystore via Capacitor plugin; the
|
||
`ablageSetzen()` hook already exists)
|
||
- [ ] Onboarding: manual token paste (required); QR scan only if it stays simple (QR generated
|
||
locally under HA `/local/`, architecture §3)
|
||
- [ ] Authenticated smoke tests of the data layer (reads, service calls, queue round-trip)
|
||
against `audi_ha_test` with a real token
|
||
- [ ] Offline UX per design brief (offline marker, visible pending queue)
|
||
|
||
### B) Infrastructure / commissioning (partly waits for FMM003 hardware)
|
||
|
||
- [ ] Switch `datametric360.app` nameservers at all-inkl to Cloudflare ("full setup") —
|
||
prerequisite for the tunnel; domain carries nothing else, so this is consequence-free
|
||
- [ ] Decide hostname split (app on apex + API on `api.` subdomain, or vice versa)
|
||
- [ ] Choose reverse proxy (Nginx Proxy Manager vs. Traefik) — **can be done before hardware**
|
||
against the existing HA API
|
||
- [ ] Define the reverse-proxy path allowlist (depends on final entity/service names)
|
||
- [ ] Install/wire the FMM003; record firmware version (Codec JSON is firmware-dependent)
|
||
- [ ] Generate TLS certificates for Mosquitto + device (small private CA); FMM003 refuses MQTT
|
||
without them
|
||
- [ ] Decide broker reachability for the vehicle: port-forward 8883 vs. VPS broker with
|
||
Mosquitto bridge over Tailscale
|
||
- [ ] Capture the first real Codec JSON message (`mosquitto_sub`/MQTT Explorer) and build the
|
||
field mapping from it — **do not guess beforehand** (explicit decision)
|
||
- [ ] Move trip detection to FMM003 ignition (reuse the `fahrterkennung.py` pattern, keep pause
|
||
tolerance); then remove `sensor.iphone_wifi_connection` from `einstellungen.py`
|
||
|
||
### C) Maintain the existing HA panel (low priority — being replaced)
|
||
|
||
- [ ] Fix documentation drift (statistics claim, INSTALL variable names, README gaps, obsolete
|
||
TODO comment) — text-only changes
|
||
- [ ] Harden `profil_lesen()` against missing/corrupt `fahrzeugprofil.json`
|
||
- [ ] Decide whether the 3 audit leftovers get fixed here or only in DataMetric360
|
||
- [ ] Optional: persist the RAM-only states (trip start, fuel low-water-mark) — deliberately
|
||
deferred; may become moot with the FMM003 switch
|
||
- [ ] Upload vehicle photos to `www/bilder/`, set `steuer.faellig` (operational data, not code)
|
||
|
||
### D) Once the panel is superseded
|
||
|
||
- [ ] **Archive** `audi-dashboard-app.js`, don't delete (settled decision, architecture §1)
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Working conventions (observed — keep them)
|
||
|
||
- German is the project language: identifiers, comments, commits, UI texts. Exceptions:
|
||
`design-system/` uses English props/JSDoc (Claude Design audience) — and **this file**, which is
|
||
English by rule.
|
||
- Decisions are logged, including rejected ones (see the Traccar section of the architecture
|
||
doc); superseded sections stay in place marked "ÜBERHOLT" rather than being deleted.
|
||
- Numbers in `de-DE` format; font weights 300/400 only, never ≥600 (only those cuts exist).
|
||
- Real vehicle/movement data stays local (`data/` contents and receipt PDFs are gitignored).
|
||
- Security principle: HA is never publicly exposed; only narrowly scoped surfaces (MQTT broker,
|
||
proxy allowlist) may be exposed, each by explicit decision.
|