Commit Graph

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Paul Nothaft 0c8ad6bbed fix(security): vet the destination project when linking a deal (#991)
linkDealToProject re-points a deal's quotes, contracts and events into
`projectId`. Its lineage guard vets the SOURCE events and its comment assumed
the route had vetted the destination — true only for attachDocumentToProject.
quoteService.create/update and contract crud.create/update take `projectId`
straight from the request body behind quotes.manage / contracts.manage, which
are permissions, not ownership; adminQuotes.js and adminContracts.js carry no
ownership guard at all.

The lineage guard did not cover it: it is skipped when the deal has produced no
event yet, which is the state of a newly created quote, and an unassigned
destination ADOPTS the deal's customer rather than rejecting it.

A scoped admin could therefore write into another admin's project, and on an
OWNERLESS project (created_by IS NULL — legacy rows migration 167 could not
attribute) escalate to a read: once the quote converts to an event it becomes
the project's only linked event, which is the condition ownedProjectsSubquery's
second branch grants ownership on.

Vetted at the service choke point all four callers share, ahead of both the
null-deal early return (callers write project_id before calling, and deal_uuid
is nullable) and the customer check (whose 422 vs 404 was an enumeration
oracle). 404 PROJECT_NOT_FOUND throughout. super_admin unaffected.
2026-08-04 16:36:12 +02:00
Paul Nothaft 7c0c0a5b7f fix(security): enforce project ownership on project + project-email routes (GHSA-wrg5, GHSA-93x4) (#960)
* fix(security): enforce project ownership (GHSA-wrg5, GHSA-93x4)

Project routes authorized on generic events.view / events.edit with NO
ownership check, so an editor-like admin could enumerate, read, update and
aggregate projects belonging to other admins' events. The project email
endpoints keyed on an email_queue id alone — any admin with events.view /
email.send could preview, resend, cancel or retry ANY queued mail by walking
ids.

The earlier 'needs a migration, deferred' assessment was wrong in one
direction and right in another: ownership IS derivable transitively via
events.project_id -> events.created_by, but only for projects that already
have a linked event. A brand-new EMPTY project has no derivable owner, which
is exactly where the create -> attach flow starts. So migration 167 adds
projects.created_by (backfilled from the single linked event owner, skipping
ambiguous multi-owner projects) and createProject finally persists the adminId
it was already being passed.

- ownedProjectIds(): union of the stored owner and the transitive path, so
  pre-167 rows and new empty projects both resolve. Reads created_by
  defensively so an instance that hasn't run 167 falls back to the transitive
  rule instead of throwing.
- requireProjectOwnership on detail/update/attach-event/attach-quote/
  attach-contract/overview; list filtered by an id allowlist (empty array
  means 'owns nothing' and must return no rows, hence null-vs-[] care).
- POST /:id/events also validates the INCOMING eventId — owning the project
  is not enough, or an editor could pull a foreign event in and read its
  rolled-up documents via /:id/overview.
- Queued-email routes scoped via email_queue.event_id. CRM document mail has
  event_id NULL and no ownable parent here, so a scoped caller is denied
  rather than guessed into access. 404 (not 403) so it isn't an id oracle.

Note: adminEmail.js:315/332 let any email.view/edit admin archive or delete
any email_queue row — the same class, pre-existing and outside these two
advisories. Left untouched and reported rather than silently widened.

* fix(security): codex round 2 — make the stored project owner authoritative (GHSA-wrg5)

The first predicate union'd 'any linked event I can see' with the stored
owner, which opened two holes:

- A project owned by admin B containing ONE legacy ownerless event became
  readable by every admin — and /:id/overview aggregates B's other events,
  invoices and emails, so a single legacy event exposed the whole project.
- Migration 167 deliberately leaves multi-owner (ambiguous) projects NULL
  rather than guessing an owner. A NULL owner was then treated as
  'everyone's', so exactly those mixed projects became globally accessible.

Now: the stored created_by wins outright, and a project without a usable
stored owner only derives access when EVERY linked event is accessible (and at
least one exists). A created_by pointing at a hard-deleted admin degrades to
'no usable owner' so the project falls back to its events instead of being
locked away — no ON DELETE SET NULL migration needed. A project with neither a
usable owner nor linked events stays super_admin-only: failing closed beats
failing open, and a super_admin can reassign it.

Also returns a knex SUBQUERY rather than a materialised id list, so a large
project count can't hit the driver's bind-parameter limit.

* fix(security): codex round 3 — enforce deal-lineage ownership on project attach (GHSA-wrg5)

requireProjectOwnership vets only the DESTINATION project, while attaching a
quote or contract cascades through linkDealToProject — which re-points every
event the deal produced into that project. An editor could therefore create an
empty project of their own, attach another admin's quote, and pull that admin's
events (plus the invoices, emails and gallery that roll up with them) into a
project they own and can read via /:id/overview. The single-customer guard did
not stand in the way: an unassigned project ADOPTS the deal's customer rather
than rejecting it.

linkDealToProject now refuses to move lineage events the actor cannot own, and
assignDocument cascades BEFORE stamping the document so a refused attach leaves
nothing half-applied (the old order committed the foreign document into the
caller's project and only then declined the cascade). The quote/contract
create+update paths, which reach the same cascade with an arbitrary project_id,
thread their adminId through as well; isSuperAdmin() resolves the role for them
and fails closed when it cannot.

Events are the only ownership signal a deal carries — quotes and contracts have
no created_by in this schema — so a lineage that produced no event still cannot
be attributed. That is a property of the CRM model, noted in the code.

Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01F211U4dDbEj4zXiyKbi9me

* docs(security): drop the stale ownership JSDoc left by the rebase (GHSA-wrg5)

Rebasing onto main (which had gained scopeEventsQuery from #957) replayed the
round-1 doc block above round-2's replacement, leaving a comment that describes
the ORIGINAL union rule — "a project is the caller's when … it has at least one
linked event they own" — directly above the code that deliberately no longer
does that. That union is the hole round 2 closed; a comment asserting it is
worse than none.

Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01F211U4dDbEj4zXiyKbi9me

---------

Co-authored-by: Paul Nothaft <paul@MacStudio-von-Paul.local>
2026-08-02 21:24:38 +02:00