feat(whatsapp): admin-selectable template parameters + reorder (#647 follow-up)

Reporter @Rekoo-PS confirmed the language fix unblocked sending, then
hit a second gap: their template uses only `{{1}} = event_name` +
`{{2}} = gallery_link`, but the legacy `buildComponents` hardcoded all
5 positional values from the `gallery_ready` shape (customer_name,
event_name, gallery_link, password_line, expiry_date). Meta rejected
with a parameter-count mismatch even after the language matched.

This adds a per-config slot list — which built-in values to send, and
in what positional order — so admins can match templates of any shape
without code changes.

## Schema (migration 138)

Additive `template_params` TEXT column on `whatsapp_configs` (default
empty string = legacy 5-slot behaviour for existing installs). Stored
as a JSON-serialized array of slot keys: `customer_name`, `event_name`,
`gallery_link`, `password_line`, `expiry_date`. Unknown / duplicate /
non-string entries are sanitized out at read time.

## Processor

- `parseTemplateParams(raw)` — defensive parser; falls back to the
  5-slot default on empty / malformed / all-invalid input.
- `buildComponents(data, metaLang, params)` — emits ONLY the listed
  slots in the listed order, computed via a small switch on slot key.
  The password line still receives the locale-specific 🔒 label and
  the empty-when-no-real-password sentinel handling.
- Processor reads `config.template_params` once per cycle and passes
  the parsed array to `buildComponents` per message.

## Admin route

- GET surfaces `template_params` as the parsed array (default 5-slot
  when null/empty).
- PUT round-trips the incoming array through `parseTemplateParams`
  before persisting, so the stored value is always the canonical
  sanitized JSON.
- Test send rebuilt to use the same `buildComponents` path so the
  admin's test message matches their configured slot shape — a
  reporter who configures 2 slots gets a 2-parameter test send, not
  the legacy 5-parameter payload.

## UI

- `WhatsAppTab` gets a checkbox + up/down list under the Template
  language field. Each slot shows its current `{{N}}` position when
  checked, an em-dash when unchecked. Live preview below the list:
  "Your template will receive: {{1}} = event_name, {{2}} = gallery_link".
- EN + DE i18n for the field labels, hint, preview, and per-slot
  human-readable names.

## Tests

- 17 unit tests in `__tests__/utils/whatsappBuildComponents.test.js`
  covering: parseTemplateParams sanitization (unknown keys, duplicates,
  non-strings, malformed JSON, all-invalid fallback, pre-parsed array
  acceptance) and buildComponents shape (reporter's 2-slot case,
  reorder, empty list, locale-specific password label, password
  sentinel handling, expiry omission).
- All 17 + the 34 existing networkValidation tests pass.

## Migration numbering

Sits at 138 on top of PR #649's migration 137. If #646 (Live Slideshow)
merges before this, #646's own 137 + 138 take precedence and this
needs renumbering to 139. Coordinated via PR #646's review thread.

## Honest caveat

Still no Meta Business API account on my side. Spec-built, sanitizer +
shape unit-tested, lint + tsc clean. End-to-end against Meta needs the
reporter (or a maintainer with an account) to verify. If a real
round-trip surfaces a mismatch, drop it in #647 and I'll iterate.
This commit is contained in:
Paul Nothaft
2026-06-21 20:51:20 +02:00
parent 4fd7709596
commit 16055cdc41
8 changed files with 426 additions and 29 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,136 @@
/**
* Unit tests for the WhatsApp template-parameter selection (#647 follow-up).
*
* Pins:
* - parseTemplateParams sanitizes unknown / non-string / duplicate keys,
* and falls back to the default 5-slot shape on empty / malformed input.
* - buildComponents emits ONLY the listed slots, in the listed order, so
* a 2-parameter template (event_name + gallery_link) sends exactly 2
* positional values — the reporter's exact case from issue #647.
* - The legacy 5-slot default still works unchanged for installs that
* haven't reconfigured.
*/
const {
buildComponents,
parseTemplateParams,
DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS,
} = require('../../src/services/whatsappProcessor');
const baseData = {
customer_name: 'Aisha',
event_name: 'Wedding 2026',
gallery_link: 'https://picpeak.example/wedding-2026',
gallery_password: 'StrongPass!',
expiry_date: '2026-12-31T00:00:00Z',
};
describe('parseTemplateParams', () => {
test('returns the default 5-slot shape for empty / null / undefined input', () => {
expect(parseTemplateParams('')).toEqual(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
expect(parseTemplateParams(null)).toEqual(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
expect(parseTemplateParams(undefined)).toEqual(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
});
test('returns the default shape for malformed JSON', () => {
expect(parseTemplateParams('{not json')).toEqual(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
});
test('returns the default shape when JSON parses to a non-array', () => {
expect(parseTemplateParams('"event_name"')).toEqual(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
expect(parseTemplateParams('{"a":1}')).toEqual(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
});
test('preserves the reporter\'s 2-slot shape', () => {
const out = parseTemplateParams(JSON.stringify(['event_name', 'gallery_link']));
expect(out).toEqual(['event_name', 'gallery_link']);
});
test('drops unknown slot keys', () => {
const out = parseTemplateParams(JSON.stringify([
'event_name', 'unknown_slot', 'gallery_link', '__proto__',
]));
expect(out).toEqual(['event_name', 'gallery_link']);
});
test('drops duplicate slot keys (first wins)', () => {
const out = parseTemplateParams(JSON.stringify([
'event_name', 'gallery_link', 'event_name',
]));
expect(out).toEqual(['event_name', 'gallery_link']);
});
test('drops non-string entries', () => {
const out = parseTemplateParams(JSON.stringify([
'event_name', 42, null, { a: 1 }, 'gallery_link',
]));
expect(out).toEqual(['event_name', 'gallery_link']);
});
test('falls back to default when every entry is invalid', () => {
const out = parseTemplateParams(JSON.stringify([
'unknown_a', 'unknown_b', null, 7,
]));
expect(out).toEqual(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
});
test('also accepts an already-parsed array (defensive)', () => {
const out = parseTemplateParams(['event_name', 'gallery_link']);
expect(out).toEqual(['event_name', 'gallery_link']);
});
});
describe('buildComponents', () => {
test('legacy default shape emits 5 positional values, gallery_ready order', () => {
const out = buildComponents(baseData, 'en_US');
expect(out).toHaveLength(5);
expect(out[0]).toBe('Aisha');
expect(out[1]).toBe('Wedding 2026');
expect(out[2]).toBe('https://picpeak.example/wedding-2026');
expect(out[3]).toBe('🔒 Password: StrongPass!');
// expiry date is locale-formatted but always non-empty for a valid date
expect(out[4]).toMatch(/\d{2}/);
});
test('reporter\'s 2-slot shape — event_name + gallery_link, in that order', () => {
const out = buildComponents(baseData, 'ar', ['event_name', 'gallery_link']);
expect(out).toEqual(['Wedding 2026', 'https://picpeak.example/wedding-2026']);
});
test('reorder: gallery_link first, event_name second', () => {
const out = buildComponents(baseData, 'en_US', ['gallery_link', 'event_name']);
expect(out).toEqual(['https://picpeak.example/wedding-2026', 'Wedding 2026']);
});
test('empty slot list emits an empty components array (admin opted into nothing)', () => {
const out = buildComponents(baseData, 'en_US', []);
expect(out).toEqual([]);
});
test('password_line uses the locale-specific label when included', () => {
const out = buildComponents(baseData, 'ar', ['password_line']);
expect(out).toEqual(['🔒 كلمة المرور: StrongPass!']);
});
test('password_line is empty when no real password is set', () => {
const out = buildComponents(
{ ...baseData, gallery_password: '' },
'en_US',
['password_line'],
);
expect(out).toEqual(['']);
});
test('password_line is empty for the "No password required" sentinel', () => {
const out = buildComponents(
{ ...baseData, gallery_password: 'No password required' },
'en_US',
['password_line'],
);
expect(out).toEqual(['']);
});
test('omits expiry_date when omitted from the slot list', () => {
const out = buildComponents(baseData, 'en_US', ['event_name']);
expect(out).toEqual(['Wedding 2026']);
});
});
@@ -0,0 +1,38 @@
/**
* Migration 138: WhatsApp template parameter selection (#647 follow-up).
*
* Adds a `template_params` column to `whatsapp_configs` that stores an
* ordered JSON array of slot keys naming which built-in values are sent
* as positional parameters to the configured Meta template (and in what
* order). Reporter @Rekoo-PS hit the gap that motivated this: their
* template body uses only `{{1}} = event_name` + `{{2}} = gallery_link`,
* but the hardcoded `buildComponents` shape always emitted 5 parameters
* matching `gallery_ready` — so Meta rejected with a parameter-count
* mismatch even after the language fix landed (migration 137).
*
* Schema: TEXT column, empty/null means "fall back to the legacy 5-slot
* shape" so installs that haven't reconfigured continue to work without
* intervention. The processor's `buildComponents` reads this column,
* parses the array, and emits only the listed slots in the listed order.
*
* Known slot keys (any other keys are ignored): `customer_name`,
* `event_name`, `gallery_link`, `password_line`, `expiry_date`.
*
* Additive + `hasColumn`-guarded. The settling number depends on the
* merge order with PR #646; flagged for renumber if that lands first.
*/
exports.up = async function (knex) {
if (!(await knex.schema.hasTable('whatsapp_configs'))) return;
if (await knex.schema.hasColumn('whatsapp_configs', 'template_params')) return;
await knex.schema.alterTable('whatsapp_configs', (table) => {
table.text('template_params').notNullable().defaultTo('');
});
};
exports.down = async function (knex) {
if (!(await knex.schema.hasTable('whatsapp_configs'))) return;
if (!(await knex.schema.hasColumn('whatsapp_configs', 'template_params'))) return;
await knex.schema.alterTable('whatsapp_configs', (table) => {
table.dropColumn('template_params');
});
};
+33 -12
View File
@@ -21,6 +21,11 @@ const { adminAuth } = require('../middleware/auth');
const { requirePermission } = require('../middleware/permissions');
const { requireFeatureFlag } = require('../middleware/requireFeatureFlag');
const { sendWhatsAppMessage } = require('../services/whatsappService');
const {
buildComponents,
parseTemplateParams,
DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS,
} = require('../services/whatsappProcessor');
const logger = require('../utils/logger');
// Gate everything behind the feature flag — operators who haven't enabled
@@ -38,6 +43,7 @@ router.get('/config', adminAuth, requirePermission('settings.view'), async (req,
access_token: '',
template_name: 'gallery_ready',
template_language: '',
template_params: DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS,
enabled: false,
});
}
@@ -47,6 +53,7 @@ router.get('/config', adminAuth, requirePermission('settings.view'), async (req,
access_token: config.access_token ? '********' : '',
template_name: config.template_name,
template_language: config.template_language || '',
template_params: parseTemplateParams(config.template_params),
enabled: Boolean(config.enabled),
});
} catch (error) {
@@ -57,7 +64,7 @@ router.get('/config', adminAuth, requirePermission('settings.view'), async (req,
router.put('/config', adminAuth, requirePermission('settings.edit'), async (req, res) => {
try {
const { phone_number_id, waba_id, access_token, template_name, template_language, enabled } = req.body;
const { phone_number_id, waba_id, access_token, template_name, template_language, template_params, enabled } = req.body;
const existing = await db('whatsapp_configs').first();
const isEnabled = Boolean(enabled);
@@ -71,11 +78,19 @@ router.put('/config', adminAuth, requirePermission('settings.edit'), async (req,
? template_language.trim().slice(0, 20)
: '';
// Template parameter selection (#647 follow-up). Round-trip through the
// processor's sanitizer so unknown / duplicate / non-string keys are
// dropped before persistence, and we always store the canonical JSON
// array shape. Empty input falls back to the legacy 5-slot default so
// existing installs keep working.
const sanitizedTemplateParams = parseTemplateParams(template_params);
const data = {
phone_number_id: phone_number_id || '',
waba_id: waba_id || '',
template_name: template_name || 'gallery_ready',
template_language: normalizedTemplateLanguage,
template_params: JSON.stringify(sanitizedTemplateParams),
enabled: isEnabled,
updated_at: new Date(),
};
@@ -139,21 +154,27 @@ router.post('/test', adminAuth, requirePermission('settings.edit'), async (req,
return res.status(400).json({ error: 'WhatsApp is not configured' });
}
// Static template parameters — the admin only needs to confirm that the
// configured Meta credentials + approved template can deliver to a real
// phone, not the per-event substitution logic.
const testComponents = [
'PicPeak Test',
'Test Gallery',
'https://example.com/gallery/test',
'',
'',
];
// Use the configured template language so non-English templates can be
// tested too (#647). Falls back to en_US for the default `gallery_ready`
// shape that ships in English.
const language = (config.template_language && config.template_language.trim()) || 'en_US';
// Build the test components through the SAME path the production queue
// uses, so the test message matches the admin's `template_params` shape
// (#647 follow-up). With a 2-slot template (event_name + gallery_link)
// we send exactly 2 positional values; with the default 5-slot shape
// we send the legacy "PicPeak Test" payload. Static placeholder data —
// the admin only needs to confirm credentials + template approval, not
// the per-event substitution logic.
const params = parseTemplateParams(config.template_params);
const testData = {
customer_name: 'PicPeak Test',
event_name: 'Test Gallery',
gallery_link: 'https://example.com/gallery/test',
gallery_password: '',
expiry_date: null,
};
const testComponents = buildComponents(testData, language, params);
const result = await sendWhatsAppMessage(phone, config, language, testComponents);
res.json({ success: true, messageId: result.messageId });
} catch (error) {
+59 -15
View File
@@ -126,16 +126,50 @@ function formatDate(raw, metaLangCode) {
}
}
// Default slot order — matches the operator-registered `gallery_ready`
// template's 5-parameter shape and preserves pre-#647 behaviour for installs
// that haven't configured `template_params`.
const DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS = ['customer_name', 'event_name', 'gallery_link', 'password_line', 'expiry_date'];
const KNOWN_TEMPLATE_PARAMS = new Set(DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS);
/**
* Parse `whatsapp_configs.template_params` (JSON array string) into a
* sanitized slot list. Unknown / non-string / duplicated keys are dropped;
* empty / malformed input falls back to the default 5-slot shape so the
* legacy `gallery_ready` template keeps working.
*/
function parseTemplateParams(raw) {
if (!raw) return DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS;
try {
const parsed = typeof raw === 'string' ? JSON.parse(raw) : raw;
if (!Array.isArray(parsed)) return DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS;
const seen = new Set();
const out = [];
for (const k of parsed) {
if (typeof k !== 'string') continue;
if (!KNOWN_TEMPLATE_PARAMS.has(k)) continue;
if (seen.has(k)) continue;
seen.add(k);
out.push(k);
}
return out.length > 0 ? out : DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS;
} catch (_) {
return DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS;
}
}
/**
* Build the positional body components for the configured template. The
* default `gallery_ready` template (operator-registered) expects:
* {{1}} customer_name
* {{2}} event_name
* {{3}} gallery_link
* {{4}} password line (with localised "🔒 Password:" prefix, or empty)
* {{5}} expiry date (or empty)
* `params` list controls which built-in values are emitted, and in what
* order — so an admin who registered a 2-parameter Meta template with
* `{{1}} = event_name, {{2}} = gallery_link` (e.g. #647) configures
* `template_params: ["event_name","gallery_link"]` and gets exactly those
* two positional values per send.
*
* Known slot keys: customer_name, event_name, gallery_link, password_line,
* expiry_date. Anything else is filtered out by parseTemplateParams.
*/
function buildComponents(data, metaLang) {
function buildComponents(data, metaLang, params = DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS) {
const label = PASSWORD_LABELS[metaLang] || PASSWORD_LABELS.en_US;
const hasRealPassword = data.gallery_password
&& data.gallery_password !== 'No password required'
@@ -143,13 +177,18 @@ function buildComponents(data, metaLang) {
const passwordLine = hasRealPassword ? `${label}: ${data.gallery_password}` : '';
const expiryLine = formatDate(data.expiry_date, metaLang);
return [
data.customer_name || '',
data.event_name || '',
data.gallery_link || '',
passwordLine,
expiryLine,
];
const valueFor = (key) => {
switch (key) {
case 'customer_name': return data.customer_name || '';
case 'event_name': return data.event_name || '';
case 'gallery_link': return data.gallery_link || '';
case 'password_line': return passwordLine;
case 'expiry_date': return expiryLine;
default: return '';
}
};
return params.map(valueFor);
}
async function getWhatsAppConfig() {
@@ -211,6 +250,7 @@ async function processWhatsAppQueue() {
// 3. en_US — hardcoded last resort.
const configLanguage = resolveLanguageCode(config.template_language);
const defaultLanguage = configLanguage || await getSystemDefaultLanguageCode();
const params = parseTemplateParams(config.template_params);
let pending;
try {
@@ -236,7 +276,7 @@ async function processWhatsAppQueue() {
const requestedLang = resolveLanguageCode(data.language);
const metaLang = requestedLang || defaultLanguage;
const components = buildComponents(data, metaLang);
const components = buildComponents(data, metaLang, params);
await sendWhatsAppMessage(item.recipient_phone, config, metaLang, components);
@@ -291,4 +331,8 @@ module.exports = {
startWhatsAppQueueProcessor,
stopWhatsAppQueueProcessor,
getWhatsAppConfig,
// Exported for the admin route's test send + unit tests (#647 follow-up).
buildComponents,
parseTemplateParams,
DEFAULT_TEMPLATE_PARAMS,
};